Scores, rubric and sources
- 01Education1 of 5
- Medium confidenceVillage schoolhouse, then briefly Latin at Kinderhook Academy and Washington Seminary; formal education ended in 1796 when he began reading law; no college. Admitted to the New York bar by 1803.[1]Highest attainment by then: 1 secondary school, 2 some college, 3 bachelor's degree, 4 master's or professional degree, 5 doctorate.
- 02WealthNo evidence
- Net worth or income against the national thresholds of the time: 1 below the median household, 3 top 5%, 5 top 0.1%.
- 03Position5 of 5
- High confidencePresident of the United States, 1837-1841.[3]Scope of the role held: 1 entry level, 3 senior manager or legislator, 5 head of state or government, or the top role of a major institution.
- 04Public standingNo evidence
- Public approval or favourability where it was measured: 1 under 20%, 3 35 to 50%, 5 over 65%.
- 05HealthNo evidence
- Documented health where an examination or disclosure exists: 5 no documented concern, 1 a serious documented condition.
- 06Misconduct0 of 5
- Medium confidenceThe presidency article describes no formal investigation or official finding; historian Laurence Hauptman's claim that the 1838 Treaty of Buffalo Creek was fraudulently imposed is an allegation, not an official finding.[3]The documented legal and ethics record within the phase, as in the misconduct meter: 0 none documented, 1 only matters resolved in their favour, 2 an open matter, 3 one finding, 4 two or three, 5 four or more. More is more documented misconduct.
- 07Social good1.5 of 5
- Low confidenceOrdered the 1838 removal of Cherokee under the 1835 Treaty of New Echota ('some 20,000 people' relocated); the Second Seminole War cost over 1,400 American servicemen; he issued a ten-hour-day order for federal workers in 1840. Judgement-heavy.[3]Assessed effects of what they did in the phase on health, safety, education, rights and the environment, from official statistics or peer-reviewed evidence: 0 clearly harmful, 2.5 mixed, 5 clearly beneficial.
- 08Economic good1.5 of 5
- Low confidencePanic of 1837 began May 10, 1837 and was followed by a five-year depression with numerous bank failures and record unemployment; he won the Independent Treasury in June 1840 and kept the budget balanced.[3]Assessed effects of what they did in the phase on efficiency, growth and fiscal sustainability, from CBO and peer-reviewed evidence, as in the good-for-society reading: 0 clearly harmful, 2.5 mixed, 5 clearly beneficial.