- 开始
- 2025年9月17日可信度 90%来自来源
Judge Dismisses Antitrust Suit Over Hermès' Birkin Sales
U.S. District Judge James Donato dismissed with prejudice the Sherman Act claims that Hermès illegally tied Birkin bag sales to other purchases, ruling the plaintiffs never defined a viable product market or showed harm to competition.
- On 17 September 2025, Judge James Donato of the Northern District of California dismissed the plaintiffs' second amended complaint against Hermès with prejudice, closing the case[1]
- The court held the plaintiffs failed to plausibly define a relevant tying product market, show Hermès held market power in it, or show real harm to competition in the tied goods (scarves, footwear, jewelry and the like)[1]
- The judge said market share claims of 60-75% for Birkin bags did not by themselves show market power without allegations that Hermès could exclude rivals or control prices[2]
- Having no remaining federal claim, the court declined to keep hearing the plaintiffs' California state-law claims; plaintiffs indicated they would appeal to the Ninth Circuit[2]
参考资料 2可信度 87%
第一项始终是图钉的来源。总体可信度是各份资料对上方所用开始和结束时间支持程度的加权平均；资料每比最新的一份旧 180 天，权重减半。
- [1]90%appliedantitrust.com/22_tying/case_studies/cavaller_hermes2024/01_ndcalif/cavalleri_ndcalif_dismissal_order2025_09_17.pdfappliedantitrust.com· 发布于 2026年9月25日· 开始 2025年9月17日 ✓· 占评分 50%
The order itself is dated "Dated: September 17, 2025" and signed by Judge James Donato, closing the case.
- [2]85%Hermès Beats Antitrust Case Over Alleged Birkin Bag Schemethefashionlaw.com· 添加于 2026年9月25日· 占评分 50%
Reports the 17 September 2025 dismissal, that it was with prejudice on the federal claims, and that the plaintiffs said they would appeal to the Ninth Circuit.[1]
建议更正
有遗漏或错误吗？用你自己的话说明：能佐证此图钉的链接、不同的开始或结束日期及理由，或缺失、有误的信息。AI 会对照此图钉的来源进行核实，搜索更好的来源，并添加任何支持你说法的页面。图钉自身的来源仍然最重要。
